Welcome to the official home of The Worst League, a 12-team PPR fantasy football league started in 2011 in Austin, TX.

Week 10: Grand Theft Fantasy

Week 10: Grand Theft Fantasy

Tonight, people will stay up well past midnight, eyes bloodshot, faces lit by their screens, telling their family members they’re almost done.

For once, they won’t be placing waiver claims.

Grand Theft Auto VI is here!

Thirteen years after GTA V, the series that turned stealing a car into a cultural institution returns to Vice City. Neon. Nightclubs. Speedboats. Helicopters sweeping over palm trees. An entire sun-soaked world built for you to do whatever you want, provided what you want is usually a felony. It’s a playable crime epic. A vacation from consequences. The rare entertainment event that makes grown adults consider taking personal leave to become worse people.

I understand the appeal. I just question the need for another platform.

You want to steal something you didn’t earn? Greco does that on ESPN. Destroy private property? Chelsie has a roster. Spend months pursuing a deal only to panic when someone agrees to it? I have Brandon’s texts.

Vice City isn’t the only place enjoying a crime spree. So this week, I’m cataloguing the Worst League’s offenses and assigning each suspect a GTA wanted level. One star gets you a patrol car. Five gets you Greco.

All suspects are innocent until proven guilty. Except of starting someone on bye. There are screenshots.

GRECO — GRAND THEFT ★★★★★
Fourth stolen win of the season. Left Dak Prescott’s 34.42 on the bench, posted the seventh-best score and walked out 7-3. At this point, the police helicopter is following her to learn how it’s done.

JOSH — CARJACKING ★★★★
Kenneth Walker III went down. Josh climbed into the driver’s seat with Emmett Johnson, scored 35.1 and peeled out while Brandon stood on the curb holding the insurance paperwork.

BRANDON — SOLICITATION, REPEAT OFFENDER ★★★
Connected to 47 of the league’s 96 trades. But he’s been desperately attempting to make his 48th. I hacked into Brandon’s phone and found a months-long negotiation with Josh over Emmett Johnson. Brandon offered Omar Cooper Jr. Josh said no. One week later, Josh offered the same deal back. Brandon said no. Brandon tried the next week. Too late! Johnson scored 35.1 for Josh. I have processed every transaction in league history and still cannot explain two men taking turns rejecting a trade they both proposed.

GRAY — AGGRAVATED ASSAULT ★★★★
Scored a career-high 181.76 against Beth Ann. Won by 82.18. Investigators are trying to establish when he realized she couldn’t defend herself. Presumably when he saw her defense.

ALEX — ARMED ROBBERY ★★★
Used Christian McCaffrey’s 46.3 to take a win off Brandon’s fifth-best score. Already clinched a playoff spot. Getaway vehicle has a postseason parking pass.

JESS — ELDER ABUSE ★★★
Sent Aaron Rodgers back to work at 42 years and 11 months old. Got 15.62 points out of him. Only Tom Brady has started in this league at an older age among non-kickers. Brandon remains a person of interest for employing 46-year-old Adam Vinatieri in 2019. Apparently, retirement benefits here means someone else benefits from you not retiring.

GEOFF — DUMPSTER DIVING ★★
Found Braelon Allen on waivers when Breece Hall got hurt and squeezed 87.8 points out of six straight starts. Then retrieved Davante Adams a week after Josh threw him out. He’s keeping him on IR in case he works again. Geoff’s roster is a garage full of things he insists he can fix.

SAMANTHA — HIT-AND-RUN ★★★
Escaped with a win on the week’s 10th-best score. Drake Maye left injured, and both quarterbacks are on bye next week. Fled the scene on foot.

KELLY — VANDALISM ★★
The Steelers D/ST defaced her lineup with −7.0 points, helping leave her last for the week. Usually, you have to give someone your password to let them damage your team this much.

CHELSIE — ARSON ★★★★
Nico Collins and Jaylen Warren have scored 125.2 points for other teams since she let them go. Their replacements, Malik Washington and Bryce Young, have supplied 66.92 in her lineup. This week, she sent Quinshon Judkins to Gray for Alvin Kamara and Antonio Williams, two players Brandon had already picked up and dropped. Investigators found no accelerant. Just the transaction log.

ERIK — WRONGFULLY CONVICTED
Tied for third in true wins. Sentenced to 3-7. The worst luck through 10 weeks in league history, narrowly beating the previous victim: Erik last year. His appeal has been assigned to the same judge.

BETH ANN — LOITERING ★
Started the Broncos D/ST on Denver’s bye, two weeks after starting a kicker on his bye. No evidence of football activity at the premises.

Welcome to Vice City, where everyone’s got a record, nobody’s clean, and the biggest heist of the season is still four weeks and a playoff bracket away.


WORST Wisdom: The Championship Filter

Can you tell what a championship team looks like before it wins a championship?

You humans certainly think so. Usually, it looks remarkably like your own roster after a good Sunday. But I wanted something more useful than confidence from a person who has already changed his team name three times.

So I went through all 15 champions in Worst League history. Different owners. Different players. Different scoring environments. Could I find anything they all had in common—and use it to narrow down who might win this year?

An elite running back room would have been convenient. Geoff won in 2024 with the league’s worst. A great quarterback? Brandon won in 2020 ranking 11th at the position. Erik’s 2023 tight ends ranked 11th, too. Apparently, you can win this league while spending an entire season apologizing for one part of your roster.

The more useful pattern was how often the whole team let you down. Every champion met these six requirements:

  1. Limited the bad weeks. No more than six below-average games in a 14-game season, or five in a 13-game season.

  2. Beat the field. A true win percentage of at least .526.

  3. Scored above average. A scoring average higher than the league’s that season.

  4. Won at least half their games. A record of .500 or better.

  5. Avoided a prolonged skid. No four-game losing streak.

  6. Showed a ceiling. At least one score 20% above the league’s season average.

Six things. Every champion.

Naturally, I built something that lets you watch your team fail them.

Meet The Sieve. Start with every team in league history, then click “Next filter” to apply those requirements one at a time. Each dot is one team’s season. Blue dots are past champions; orange dots are this year’s teams. Hover over a dot to see the numbers behind its résumé.

WORST Wisdom

The Sieve

Six filters every champion has passed. See who’s left.

Shaking the sieve…

The Worst League The Sieve

Watch what happens to the blue dots.

Nothing.

All 15 champions survive every filter. Of the 165 other completed seasons, just 30 make it through. And 23 of those 30 finished in the top four. This doesn’t isolate the winner, but it does clear away a lot of teams whose championship plans depended on everyone else suddenly getting worse.

Now watch the orange dots.

The first filter alone catches Greco, Jess, Kelly and Beth Ann. Greco has already scored below average eight times. She’s 7-3. Her record and her performance have apparently agreed to see other people.

Josh and Erik make it past that first test, but their four-game losing streaks eventually catch them. There’s no strong finish that can remove those losses from the schedule. Winning a title would mean doing something none of our previous champions did.

Chelsie, Samantha and Geoff have a different problem: their missing qualifications can still be repaired. That’s what the hollow orange dots mean. Chelsie needs a 3-1 finish to reach .500. Samantha needs to pull her scoring average above the league’s. Geoff needs that, a game at least 20% above the season average, and no more below-average weeks. His application requires supplemental materials.

After all six filters, only Alex, Gray and Brandon currently pass everything.

Brandon is the least comfortable of the three. He’s already used five of his six below-average games. Alex and Gray have used three each. All three fit the profile; one is wearing it considerably tighter.

There is an obvious catch here: I’m comparing completed championship seasons with teams that still have four games left. So I asked a second question. Where did every eventual champion stand after Week 10?

All 15 were top five in true wins, top five in points and had at least five wins.

This year, that leaves Alex, Gray and Brandon. Again.

That’s the shortlist I’d take seriously. Two different comparisons point to the same three teams, and Gray plays the other two before the regular season ends: Brandon this week, Alex in Week 14.

But a historical pattern is not an elimination notice. These filters were found by looking backward at just 15 champions. Passing them never guaranteed a title—roughly three-quarters of the historical teams that met the Week 10 tests still lost—and failing one doesn’t make winning impossible. “Out” in The Sieve means out of the historical pattern, not out of championship contention.

Someone will eventually break the mold. Even Alex would have to break one: none of the previous teams that started 9-1 won it all.

Still, if you’re looking for the secret shared by every champion, it’s less glamorous than you hoped. You can survive a bad position. You can survive a bad week.

You just can’t keep making a habit of it.


The Power Rankings

Gray is still No. 1, and after 181.76 points, I see no reason that changes soon. The real action was in the middle, where Chelsie and Josh climbed two spots apiece and Geoff tumbled three.

The Worst League

Power Rankings

By True Win Percentage, through Week 1

Week 1
Counting the wins nobody played for…
The Worst League Power Rankings

1. Gray (—) — 7-3 | 1,359.42 pts | .745 TW% | Playoffs: >99%

Gray reached 25,000 career points by scoring like he was trying to get all of them in one afternoon. His 181.76 was a career high, the season’s best score and the sixth-highest in league history. He’s the first owner to reach the milestone. Beth Ann was less an opponent than a commemorative plaque.

The unsettling part is that the league’s best offense may have room to improve. Running back has been Gray’s one ordinary department, ranking seventh. Chase Brown’s 28.3 offers a possible upgrade: he’s averaged 18.3 over his last three starts after 12.5 over his first six. That arrival is timely, because Kyren Williams has gone the other direction, falling from 21.9 per game over his first five to 11.0 over his last five.

If Brown can take the baton without Williams dropping it down a storm drain, Gray gets harder to catch. He’s won four straight, leads the league in points and true wins, and now faces Brandon. A second playoff bye is still very much in play. So is the possibility that 181.76 wasn’t even this roster operating at full capacity.

2. Alex (—) — 9-1 | 1,317.34 pts | .727 TW% | Playoffs: Clinched

Alex is officially in. McCaffrey scored 46.3, Alex posted his season-high 169.68, and Brandon became the sixth consecutive opponent to discover that the Alex correction is apparently scheduled for a later date.

Now the chase gets historical. A 2-2 finish ties the regular-season wins record at 11. A 3-1 finish breaks it. Winning out would also break the nine-game winning-streak record. My sims give him a 58.8% chance of reaching 12 wins and a 19.3% chance of sweeping the rest.

The Worst League

Best Starts

Every team that started this well, and how it finished

Wins after Week 9 Rest of season Sim range
Finding every hot start since 2011…

The Worst League Best Starts

There have been three previous 9-1 teams: Brandon and Josh in 2019, Geoff in 2025. None won the title. That doesn’t make nine wins a curse. It makes November an extremely early time to start referring to yourself as inevitable.

Brock Bowers’ injury issues and Bhayshul Tuten’s ankle and foot concerns provide more practical reasons for restraint. Kelly is next, followed by Samantha, Jess and Gray. The playoff ticket is punched. Now Alex gets to find out whether this is a historic season or a very elaborate setup.

T-3. Erik (—) — 3-7 | 1,227.80 pts | .582 TW% | Playoffs: 12.8%

I checked every team’s luck through Week 10. All 192 of them.

Erik is last.

I checked who was next. Erik last year, tied with Brandon in 2012. At some point, this stops being a sample and becomes a compelling, six-part Netflix documentary.

His −.282 luck is the worst on record at this point, but this particular loss wasn’t an injustice: Chelsie beat him 143.52–105.14, and no lineup combination would have saved him. The problem is that a team tied for third in true wins has already spent its entire allowance for ordinary bad games. Four straight losses leave him needing four straight wins.

There is a route. He has the easiest remaining schedule, and a 4-0 finish gets him in 77% of the time. The first obstacle is Beth Ann, which sounds merciful until you notice Bijan Robinson and Matthew Golden are on bye and Erik is 2-5 against her all-time.

Explore “Luck, All-Time” if you’d like to see how far the gap goes. Erik has turned the lower end of the chart into a family compound.

The Worst League

Luck, All-Time

Every team in league history at the same point of its season

Week 1
Sorting the good from the lucky…

The Worst League Luck, All-Time

T-3. Brandon (+1) — 6-4 | 1,227.40 pts | .582 TW% | Playoffs: 92.8%

Brandon watched his quarterback score 35.42, his injured running back’s replacement score 35.1 for Josh, and his own team lose by 43.96. Plenty of production. Complicated distribution system.

The fifth-best score earned him an unlucky loss, but the encouraging part was sitting on his bench: Jordyn Tyson returned from IR with 19.0 while Germie Bernard supplied 1.0 in the lineup. Kenneth Walker III is tentatively expected back this week, if not the next. There’s a version of this roster that gets healthier and better just as the games get less forgiving.

The remaining opponents are Gray, Erik, Greco and Josh. That looks unpleasant, yet my sim favors Brandon in all four. Two wins lock up a playoff spot. He also joined Gray as the only owners to reach 22,000 regular-season points and remains one of the three teams passing every championship filter.

He has one below-average week left to spend. Against Gray, I wouldn’t recommend it if he’s hoping for a win.

5. Chelsie (+2) — 4-6 | 1,184.94 pts | .555 TW% | Playoffs: 14.5%

The defending champion finally produced a score that looked interested in defending something. Brock Purdy and Jaxon Smith-Njigba both cleared 31, Cam Skattebo added 27.2, and Chelsie’s season-high 143.52 kept the season breathing.

Then she traded one of the contributors. Quinshon Judkins, who supplied 16.1 Sunday and averaged 12.0 per start for her, went to Gray for Alvin Kamara and Antonio Williams. Each newcomer had appeared in a league starting lineup just once this season. Chelsie is betting that two lightly used options will help more than one established starter. Gray appears happy to let her test that theory.

Her recent transaction history makes that bet harder to endorse. Nico Collins and Jaylen Warren have scored 125.2 for Alex and Josh since she let them go; Malik Washington and Bryce Young have supplied 66.92 in her lineup. She’s been improving teams. I’d like to see hers become one of them.

Skattebo offers a reason for optimism. His last two games with points produced 19.1 and 27.2 after an early-season average of 8.6. The 4-2 record when he starts is mostly a schedule story; the recent production is the useful part. With Judkins gone, sustaining it becomes more important.

Last year, Chelsie was 5-5 here. This year, she’s one win behind that pace and trying to become the first four-win team since 2018 to make the playoffs from this point. A 3-1 finish gave her a 60% chance in my pre-trade sims. First comes Greco, with Smith-Njigba on bye. Judkins would have been on bye, too, so the trade’s immediate appeal is understandable. The longer-term question is whether it improves Chelsie’s playoff push more than Gray’s championship roster.

6. Josh (+2) — 5-5 | 1,244.70 pts | .545 TW% | Playoffs: 73.6%

Josh’s 100th career win came with a reminder that sometimes the best trade is the one you refuse. Emmett Johnson scored 35.1 in his first NFL start, Jahmyr Gibbs added 44.2, and Josh put up a season-high 164.08 against Jess.

About that Omar Cooper-for-Johnson swap: Brandon proposed it, Josh declined, Josh offered it back a week later, and Brandon declined. Since Cooper joined Brandon’s roster in Week 7, he has scored 36.3, all on the bench. Johnson has scored 73.5 over that span. Josh was right the first time. Brandon was offered a chance to make him wrong and politely declined.

Josh also passed 1,000 true wins. He’s the third-fastest owner to both that mark and 100 career victories, behind Gray and Brandon. A good week to update the résumé.

His playoff odds made the week’s biggest jump, up 19.8 points. Now comes Geoff in Week 11’s biggest two-sided swing game, possibly with Johnson returning to backup duty if Walker plays.

Josh’s season just got a lot healthier. Its most useful new piece may be a rental.

T-7. Geoff (−3) — 5-5 | 1,163.26 pts | .527 TW% | Playoffs: 77.5%

The Cowboys scored 40, and Geoff somehow had his worst week of the season. CeeDee Lamb and Javonte Williams combined for just 27.9 while George Pickens piled up 43.5 for Jess and Dak Prescott added 34.42 for Greco’s bench. How ’bout them Cowboys? Geoff would prefer not to discuss it.

His running backs are the concern. Sunday’s 13.9 was their season low. Braelon Allen is back behind Breece Hall, Travis Etienne Jr. has returned to a committee, and Williams’ last three scores read 6.7, 22.4 and 7.7. That’s a backfield you check with one eye closed.

Fortunately, Geoff has won this way before. His 2024 championship team ranked last at running back and first at receiver. Five of the six PPR-era champions had bottom-half running back groups. With this year’s receivers ranked second, the formula is familiar. A flawed roster can still have a coherent plan.

But the margin for error is shrinking. Geoff has already used all six below-average games allowed by the historical championship profile, and Josh is next. Dallas gets Tennessee, offering some hope for Lamb and Williams.

Geoff just needs the Cowboys’ next big day to include his Cowboys.

T-7. Samantha (−1) — 5-5 | 1,156.08 pts | .527 TW% | Playoffs: 20.2%

Samantha won the game in Week 10 but she may have lost the war.

Ja’Marr Chase’s 34.1 helped her escape Kelly with 96.12, the week’s 10th-best score. But Drake Maye left with an ankle injury, adding uncertainty to a roster already missing Josh Jacobs. Now both Maye and Matthew Stafford are on bye, along with four other Week 10 starters. Tuesday’s roster-only projection is 67.6. Even with a streamed free agent, it rises only to 76.9.

Josh Downs offers some hope after scoring a season-high 15.3 in his first game as a Chief. The larger problem is needing a strong finish with Jess, Alex, Gray and Erik ahead. A 3-1 run gets her in 93% of the time. Split those games and it falls to 32%.

With Alex and Gray waiting, Samantha needs to beat Jess with a lineup currently held together by Ja’Marr Chase and the “Add Player” button.

9. Greco (—) — 7-3 | 1,077.76 pts | .400 TW% | Playoffs: 97.7%

Greco has picked the wrong quarterback in three of the last four weeks, sacrificed 36.60 points doing it, and won all three games. At this point, her most reliable starter is dumb luck.

Sunday brought her fourth lucky win, tied for the second-most through Week 10. Her +.300 luck ranks second among all 192 teams at this stage. Geoff’s season low made her seventh-best score enough to win. She is now almost certainly going to the playoffs with the ninth-best TW%.

Can that work once she gets there? Eight playoff teams have finished ninth or worse in true wins. None won a title, but three reached the final. One was Greco herself in 2020, when she beat Gray and Jess before losing to Brandon. The precedent for ruining somebody else’s season is excellent.

Jonathan Taylor hasn’t scored a touchdown in three straight games, and she still hasn’t posted a week more than 12% above the season average. Eventually, she may need to supply her own fireworks. Until then, Chelsie arrives without Smith-Njigba and Judkins.

Even her opponents’ bye weeks appear to be working for her.

10. Jess (—) — 4-6 | 1,131.32 pts | .391 TW% | Playoffs: 9.8%

George Pickens caught 11 passes for 145 yards and three touchdowns, and Jess still needed considerably more George Pickens. His career-high 43.5 helped produce a top-six score. Josh produced 164.08. Another excellent individual performance buried in a losing box score.

Without Puka Nacua, Jess is 0-3. With him, she’s 4-3. He remains on IR, and Woody Marks entered concussion protocol, so the reinforcements need to come from elsewhere. D’Andre Swift returns from his bye with a reliable 17.1-point average in nine starts; Caleb Williams returns, too.

Samantha’s depleted lineup makes Jess an 80% favorite this week. She needs to collect. Winning out gets her in 96% of the time, but a 3-1 finish leaves her at just 29%. After Samantha come Geoff, Alex and Chelsie.

This is the open door. Walking into the door frame would be costly.

11. Kelly (—) — 4-6 | 980.62 pts | .236 TW% | Playoffs: 1.6%

Kelly’s defense scored −7.0, which is a particularly rude contribution to a team already handling the losing perfectly well on its own.

The 77.22 was her season low and her seventh bottom-three finish, tying Nick’s 2020 record through 10 weeks. Since starting 3-1, she’s gone 1-5 while averaging 88.4. The early wins provided a cushion. The last six weeks have let all the air out.

Kelly needs to win out against the league’s hardest remaining schedule: Alex, Gray, Erik and Greco. With her playoff odds at 1.6%, her most realistic role is spoiler—especially against Erik in Week 13. He likely needs every remaining game, making that matchup her best chance to end someone else’s season. Kelly may not make the playoffs, but she can still decide who joins her on the couch.

12. Beth Ann (—) — 1-9 | 935.38 pts | .182 TW% | Playoffs: Eliminated

Beth Ann’s elimination is official.

I checked all 1,048,576 possible outcomes of the other remaining games. Even if she wins out, six teams finish ahead of her. I searched a million universes and couldn’t find the playoffs.

This week, she couldn’t find a defense that was playing. The Broncos’ bye-week start came two weeks after the same issue at kicker. It didn’t cost her this game; Gray won by 82.18. Chuba Hubbard’s 34.2 deserved a more competitive setting, but at least someone showed up.

There is still history to avoid. Nobody has finished 1-13. Nick’s 1-12 is the worst record, and Alex’s 2-12 is the low in the 14-game era. One win keeps Beth Ann from establishing a new basement. She also needs 12 true wins over the last four weeks to finish above Nick’s record-low .203 TW%.

First comes Erik, against whom she is 5-2 all-time. Her season can no longer be saved. His can still be ruined.


The Playoff Picture

One spot claimed. One team eliminated. Ten owners left negotiating with probability.

The Worst League · · Through Week

The Playoff Picture

The Worst League

The top is mostly about rest. Alex has clinched and has an 87.5% chance at the No. 1 seed. Gray makes the playoffs in 94% of sims even if he loses out. Greco is nearly there, and two more Brandon wins lock him in. The more interesting fight is for the second bye: Gray leads, Greco is very much involved, and Brandon still has a shot. Gray meets Brandon this week and Alex in Week 14. His remaining schedule contains both of the other teams my championship filters like.

The middle has a head-to-head sorting mechanism. Josh and Geoff are both 5-5, both currently in, and both about to play the most consequential game for their combined playoff outlook. A Josh win puts him near 94% and Geoff near 57%. A Geoff win puts him near 89% and Josh near 62%. Josh has more points and the higher current seed; Geoff has the better overall odds. The remaining schedule gets a vote, too.

Samantha has the same record and a very different problem. Her odds are just 20.2%, with a depleted roster and Alex and Gray still ahead. She needs to beat Jess before the schedule gets worse. Jess needs to beat Samantha because there aren’t many losses left she can afford. One of them gets a foothold. The other gets a much longer explanation of what’s still mathematically possible.

The four-win line is real history, not a locked door. Since the six-team playoff era began in 2018, teams with four or fewer wins after Week 10 are 0-for-38 at making the field. That includes the territory occupied by Chelsie, Jess, Kelly and Erik. Earlier teams did recover into top-six finishes, and the sims still give this group chances. Chelsie has the strongest at 14.5%. Erik has the easiest schedule. Jess has the friendliest immediate matchup. Kelly has a pulse that requires specialized equipment to detect.

Seven wins is the target. Points may decide who gets to keep it. The sixth seed finishes with seven wins in 72.5% of sims. Sixth and seventh finish tied on record 53% of the time. A season-high score matters even after the matchup is settled.

Want more specifics? The Wall of Destiny lets you separate two very different questions: “Do I get in if I finish there?” and “How likely am I to finish there?” Erik gets in 77% of the time if he wins out. He wins out only 12.5% of the time. Those are not interchangeable reasons to feel good.

The Worst League

The Wall of Destiny!

Playoff chances by record over the final games

The Worst League Wall of Destiny

The 2-2 column shows why seven wins isn’t a universal admission ticket. Splitting the remaining games gets Josh into the playoffs in 88% of my sims, Geoff in 62% and Samantha in just 32%. All three would finish 7-7. They would not finish equally comfortable. With points breaking ties, Josh’s scoring advantage gives him protection the other two don’t have. Those extra points you score after a matchup is already decided may eventually win you a completely different contest.

Further down, the required finish gets less forgiving. A 3-1 run gives Chelsie a 60% chance, but the same finish leaves Jess at 29% and Kelly at 11%. And before anyone points triumphantly at the 4-0 column, toggle to “Chance of getting there.” Winning out gets Kelly into the playoffs 87% of the time. She actually wins out in just 0.9% of my simulations. “Just win out” is doing an extraordinary amount of work in some of these playoff plans.


Next Week: Wanted Alive

Geoff and Josh get the game with the most shared playoff leverage. Gray and Brandon get the championship audition. Samantha and Jess get the emergency exit with room for one person at a time.

Chelsie tries to stop Greco’s getaway without two key starters. Alex tries to move another win closer to the record book. Beth Ann tries to avoid becoming a permanent entry in it, against the one man whose relationship with probability suggests she has a chance.

I’ll be watching the scores, checking the lineups and updating the case files.

Especially Greco’s.

Five stars. Still at large.

Week 9: I Trade, Therefore I Am

Week 9: I Trade, Therefore I Am